Valentine’s Day Gift Guide: Natural Color Diamonds

Valentine’s Day is right around the corner. Whether you’re playing Cupid or searching for the perfect gift for your significant other, Valentine’s Day is a chance to add another chapter to your love story. Famously one of the most popular days to pop the question, Valentine’s Day is synonymous with roses, chocolates, and diamonds. 

While engagement season runs from November to February, Valentine’s Day is when most people decide to get down on one knee. Whether you’re searching for a gift for your spouse or significant other, natural color diamonds are a modern heirloom they’ll fall head over heels for. 

Our diamond connoisseurs have curated the world’s largest collection of natural color diamonds, creating customized diamond jewelry and bespoke engagement rings. This Valentine’s Day gift guide shares our top recommendations for bespoke engagement rings and color diamond jewelry for the season of love.

Natural Color Diamond Engagement Rings

While the modern engagement ring can be traced back to 1886, a bespoke engagement ring allows you to put your own twist on this symbol of love. You deserve an engagement ring as unique as your love story. 

Whether you’re shopping for a classic engagement ring or a vintage-inspired piece, Langerman brings you one step closer to asking that all-important question. We can help you design the engagement ring of your dreams.

1. Yellow-Orange Three Stone Ring

This chic three-stone ring is perfect for the bohemian at heart with a 1.08-carat Cognac diamond surrounded by two brilliant-cut colorless diamonds. Its understated profile makes it the perfect alternative to a vintage engagement ring. The three diamonds symbolize the past, present, and future of the couple, honoring years spent together and the years to come.

2. Lime Diamond Engagement Ring

This white gold bespoke engagement ring is a contemporary classic with a 0.29-carat natural fancy Lime oval diamond. The halo silhouette is one of the most popular choices for modern couples. 

3. Canary Yellow Diamond Ring

Put your natural color diamond center stage with this showstopping 1-carat natural Canary diamond on a band with colorless melees. It’s the perfect match for fans of statement rings and a diamond alternative to citrine to represent a November birthstone. This undeniably sophisticated ring is also easy to mix and match with our wedding band collection.

4. Gray Diamond Tension Set Ring

Think outside the box with this tension-setting engagement ring, which features a 0.30-carat gray round brilliant diamond. A gray diamond solitaire nestled in between curved bands exudes contemporary enchantment beyond the minimalistic look of a single stone.

5. Pink Pear Diamond Ring

Marilyn Monroe once said that “diamonds are a girl’s best friend” and this ring might just be the perfect best friend candidate. This striking Pink Pear Diamond Ring showcases a 0.80 carat pink pear-shaped diamond framed by a double halo of matching pink and colorless diamonds atop a split shoulder shank. The design beautifully displays color and sparkle from all angles.

6. Intense Pink Radiant Diamond

One of our newest bespoke engagement rings, this 0.11-carat natural color diamond is an understated classic and perfect for the bride-to-be who prefers a minimalistic look. 

Need more help with prepping for an engagement? Check out our other blog, How to Prepare for the Engagement Season.

Color Diamond Jewelry for Valentine’s Day

Jewelry is one of the most intimate and romantic gifts you can buy. It’s a gift that will always be cherished as a symbol of your love and a reminder of a specific time in your relationship. Color diamond jewelry is the perfect way to commemorate a milestone anniversary or as a luxury Valentine’s Day gift. 

1. Interlocking Color Diamond Eternity Rings

Are you looking for a Valentine’s Day gift with extra significance? These interlocking eternity rings can represent your family or important phases of your relationship. Featuring sparkling round brilliants in four-prong settings these rings can be personalized with the color diamonds of your choice, creating an endless row of fire and vibrancy. 

2. Fancy Brown Solitaire Ring

Meet the cocktail ring that is the ultimate plus-one. This impressive 5.51-carat fancy brown diamond sits on a classic 6-prong setting, enhancing the beauty of this natural diamond ring.

3. Champagne Diamond Earrings with White Diamond Halo

Nothing says understated luxury like a pair of solitaire diamond studs. These champagne diamond stud earrings are the perfect match for a halo engagement ring with a feminine, vintage-inspired look. This is the ultimate Valentine’s Day gift for the woman who counts Grace Kelly or Audrey Hepburn amongst her style muses. 

4. Intense Yellow Diamond Earrings

Shopping for diamond stud earrings with a twist? These earrings are the perfect way to explore color diamond jewelry with natural Canary diamonds on an 18k yellow gold bezel. These modern bezel settings enhance the vivid, rich hue of the diamonds, creating a radiance within the petite design.

5. Purplish Pink 4 Prong Stud Earring

Earring stacking is one of the biggest jewelry trends for 2025. This dramatic 0.54-carat fancy intense purplish pink diamond is perfect for a second stud piece or for mixing and matching with other natural diamond earrings.

6. Pink Diamond Pendant with Halo

Pink diamonds aren’t just for Valentine’s Day. This 0.37-carat fancy orangy-pink radiant cut diamond has a colorless halo and sits on an 18k rose gold chain. Pink and colorless diamonds nestled in a pendant that stays centered on a delicate chain make this necklace not only enviable but right on-trend. It’s the perfect memento for your first Valentine’s Day. 

7. Oval Champagne Diamond Necklace with Halo

Give your significant other the gift of a signature diamond pendant to wear every day. This dazzling necklace has a 1-carat oval champagne diamond surrounded by a halo of colorless diamonds. 

8. Yellow, Cognac, Olive, and Colorless Diamonds Tennis Bracelets

Every woman deserves a diamond tennis bracelet. The epitome of ‘quiet luxury”, these tennis bracelets feature stunning natural color diamonds, highlighted alongside a string of colorless diamonds for a subtle statement. 

Customized Diamond Jewelry as a Modern Heirloom

Shopping for color diamond jewelry can be challenging, especially if your significant other is a jewelry enthusiast. Buying a natural color diamond as a Valentine’s Day gift gives your partner the freedom to choose if they add the stone to their existing collection or incorporate it into a piece of customized diamond jewelry. You can collaborate with your partner to create a modern heirloom to pass down to the next generation. 

We have a wide selection of fancy color diamonds which allowing you to find the perfect match for your loved one. Choose a natural color diamond that matches their birthstone or their eyes, or that compliments other customized diamond jewelry, like a bespoke engagement ring or diamond bracelet. 

1. 0.51ct Natural Pear Shape Pink Diamond 

This showstopping 0.51-carat pear-shaped fancy pink diamond is a stunning heirloom and ideal as the centerpiece for a bespoke engagement ring.

2. 1.03ct Natural Orange Diamond

Bring your dream customized diamond jewelry to life with this 1.0-carat pear-shaped Pumpkin diamond from Congo. This diamond can be incorporated into a bespoke engagement ring or showstopping necklace for black-tie events. 

3. Natural Purple Diamond Triangle 0.10ct

Start your diamond collection or create a classic everyday piece with this 0.10-carat triangle-shaped fancy purplish-pink natural diamond from Australia.

4. Oval 0.50ct Natural Yellow Diamond

The oval shape remains one of the most popular for customized diamond jewelry. This 0.50 carat oval Canary diamond has endless possibilities for customized diamond jewelry.

5. 0.53ct Natural Oval Green Diamond 

Green diamonds are one of the most unique, and the perfect choice for investing in your diamond collection or creating a truly one-of-a-kind piece. This 0.53-carat Olive color diamond has a brilliant cut and is sourced from Central Africa. 

Shop for Natural Color Diamonds for Valentine’s Day

At Langerman, we’re honored to be part of your love story this Valentine’s Day. Do you have a questions regarding natural color diamonds or color diamond jewelry? Need a little help shopping for your Valentine’s Day gift? Get in touch with our diamond experts at contact@langerman-diamonds.com and we will be more than happy to help.